Roland
Barthes--The Structuralist Activity
Structuralism is an activity--it is "the controlled
succession of a certain number of mental operations.
The goal of all stucturalist activity is to reconstruct an
'object' in such a way as to manifest thereby the rules of
functioning (the "functions") of this object."
This reconstruction is called the simulacrum. "The
simulacrum is intellect added to object." The
simulacrum is essentially the representation the critic makes
of the sensuous manifold which is the object.
Structuralism involves two operations:
1) dissection--"find[ing] in it [the simulacrum]
certain mobile fragments whose differential situation engenders
a certain meaning"; and
2) articulation--discovering or establishing for the
units posited by the above activity "certain rules of
association."
The object of structuralism is not man endowed with meanings,
but man fabricating meanings."
*
For
Barthes, structuralism is "not a school, nor even a
movement." Barthes defines structuralism as an activity--it
is "the controlled succession of a certain number of mental
operations. . . . The goal of all stucturalist activity,
whether reflexive or poetic, is to reconstruct an 'object' in
such a way as to manifest thereby the rules of functioning (the
"functions") of this object." In the
structuralist activity, "creation or reflection are . . . a
veritable fabrication of a world which resembles the first
[original] one, not in order to copy it but to render it
intelligible." This copy of the original world or object is
what Barthes refers to as the simulacrum. "The
simulacrum is intellect added to object." The
simulacrum is essentially the representation the critic makes
of the sensuous manifold which is the object; the ctitic
selects out of an infinity of perceptual possibilities inherent
in the object a certain number of characteristics on which to
focus, thus building a critical response to the object on the
basis of the reconstruction or re-presentation of the object.
Structuralism
involves two operations:
1) dissection--"find[ing] in it [the simulacrum]
certain mobile fragments whose differential situation engenders
a certain meaning"; and
2) articulation--discovering or establishing for the
units posited by the above activity "certain rules of
association."
The simulacrum,
analyzed in this manner, "does not render the world"
as it is found by the critic--in its sensuous entirety. This is
impossible; no one of us can process with equal attention all of
the sense data we receive each second--if we were unable to
filter out the vast majority of such data we would be
functionaly insane. The simulacrum, therefore is a kind of
representation of the world as seen through such a selective
filtering process; "it manifests a new category of the
object, which is neither the real nor the rational, but the functional
. . . . it highlights the strictly human process by which men
give meaning to things. . . . Ultimately, one might say that the
object of structuralism is not man endowed with meanings, but
man fabricating meanings." It is this meaning-making
activity which is the structuralist--and human activity. |