Shelley--A
Defense of Poetry
Two categories of "mental action":
1) Reason--"mind contemplating the relations borne by one
thought to another."
Reason analyzes--taking things apart to determine the
relations between diverse parts
2) Imagination--"mind acting upon those thoughts so as to
color them with its own light, and composing from them, as from
elements, other thoughts, each containing within itself the
principle of its own integrity."
Imagination synthesizes--bringing together diverse
elements to form a unity connecting things previously
unconnected:
Poetry is "the expression of the imagination."
Poets are those people whose "faculty of approximation to
the beautiful . . . exists in excess."
"Poets are the hierophants of an unapprehended inspiration
. . . the unacknowledged legislators of the world."
The poet is an author of "revolutions in opinion."
The poet "participates in the eternal, the infinite, and
the one."
Poetry can have an edifying moral effect: "the great
instrument of moral good is the imagination."
This moral effect comes down to love: "The great secret of
morals is love; or a going out of our own nature, and an
identification of ourselves with the beautiful which exists in
thought, action, or person, not our own."
Imagination unites and synthesizes; poetry--"the expression
of the imagination"--facilitates the process of "going
out of our own nature."
*
Shelley
divides "mental action" into two categories:
1) reason--"mind contemplating the relations borne by
one thought to another"; and 2)
imagination--"mind acting upon those thoughts so as to
color them with its own light, and composing from them, as from
elements, other thoughts, each containing within itself the
principle of its own integrity." More simply stated, reason
analyzes--taking things apart to determine the
relations between diverse parts; imagination synthesizes--bringing
together diverse elements to form a unity connecting things
previously unconnected:
"Reason respects the differences, and imagination the
similitudes of things. Reason is to the imagination as the
instrument to the agent, as the body to the spirit, as the
shadow to the substance."
Shelley, having
established his notion of the primacy of imagination over
reason, defines poetry as "the expression of the
imagination." Poets are those people whose
"faculty of approximation to the beautiful . . . exists in
excess." Shelley isn't speaking here merely of poets
(makers) of language; rather, he widens his definition to
include "authors of language and of music, of the dance,
and architecture, and statuary, and painting . . . institutors
of laws, and the founders of civil society." Because
Shelley widens his definition of poetry (making) to "the
expression of the imagination," he ultimately extends the
label "poet" to all of us. "Making" and
imagining are what we all do, in one way or another. Shelley's
democratic instincts here are the reverse of the hierarchical
ideas of Plato.
The poet--in
this case the "great" poet--is an author of
"revolutions in opinion." The poet "participates
in the eternal, the infinite, and the one"--revealing
the Platonic/Plotinian roots of Shelley's thought. Poetry
"awakens and enlarges the mind itself by rendering it the
receptacle of a thousand unapprehended combinations of
thought." Poetry can--and does--have an edifying moral
effect, but this effect is not to be achieved through simple
didacticism; rather, "the great instrument of moral good is
the imagination." Imagination unites and synthesizes, while
reason divides and analyzes. Shelley's morality finally comes
down to love: "The great secret of morals is love; or a
going out of our own nature, and an identification of ourselves
with the beautiful which exists in thought, action, or person,
not our own." This is precisely the effect poetry
achieves--an ecstasy (literally a standing outside the self), a
transcendence of the Self through identification with that which
is Other. This is a personalized, humanized, less exclusively
subject/object oriented adaptation of Schopenhauer's notion of
aesthetic arrest. The identification can be with not merely an
object, such as a tree, or a painting, or even a poem, but with
another person:
"A man . . . must put himself in the place of another
and of many others; the pains and pleasures of his species must
become his own."
This identification of Self with Other, this "love,"
is the moral effect--if not the moral purpose--of
poetry.
Shelley credits
the poetry of the "Provencal trouveurs," Dante,
Petrarch, and Shakespeare with raising the status of women--a
claim which may be somewhat overstated.
Shelley goes on
to defend poetry and poets against the challenges of "reasoners
and mechanists" who allege that reason is more useful than
imagination. Pleasure is what "a sensitive and intelligent
being seeks." He divides pleasure into two
categories: 1) the "durable, universal and
permanent"--"whatever strengthens and purifies the
affections, enlarges the imagination, and adds spirit to
sense"; and 2) the "transitory and
particular"--"that which banishes the importunity of
the wants of our animal nature," surrounds men with the
"security of life," and generally proceeds from
"motives of personal advantage." Shelley
identifies the former pleasure with imagination, while
identifying the latter pleasure with reason.
Shelley takes
the Platonic view of poetry as primarily a product of
inspiration, and he assigns the poet a divine function:
"Poets are the hierophants of an unapprehended inspiration
. . . the unacknowledged legislators of the world." |